Formerly Caroline's Cupcakes & Cafe
All Gourmet cupcakes are $1.99 each unless otherwise noted. Price per dozen is $21.00. You may mix and match any cupcakes from the bakery case on that day's menu. You can also order any flavor that's not on the daily menu, as long as you order a full dozen or more of any one flavor. Please call if you have any other questions.
Banana Toffee - Our banana cake with toffee chips baked into the batter, topped with a vanilla buttercream frosting and more toffee chips on top.
M&M - Yellow cake with crushed M&M's, Vanilla M&M buttercream frosting with mini M&M candy for a finishing touch.
Peanut Butter & Banana - Banana cake with mini chocolate chips baked in, peanut butter buttercream frosting with a dark chocolate drizzle.
Butterscotch Bourbon - Sweet Butterscotch cake topped with a Kentucky bourbon cream cheese frosting, garnished with butterscotch chips.
Strawberry Lemonade - Strawberry Lemonade cake with strawberry lemonade buttercream frosting, topped with a LemonHead candy and Twizzler straw.
Mint Oreo - Chocolate cake with mint cream filling, topped with a mint Oreo buttercream frosting, garnishsed with an Oreo cookie crumble.
Cherry Limeade - Cherry cake with a hint of lime, topped with a lime zest buttercream frosting, garnishsed with a cherry on top.
Chocolate Marshmallow Cream - Our classic chocolate cake, with a marshmallow fluff filling, topped with chocolate buttercream and a dollop of marshmallow fluff.
Orange OK - An orange cake, with a vanilla cream filling, topped with a mandarin buttercream frosting and a dollop more of vanilla cream. Named after owner Jonathan's former band!
Banana Split - Our banana cake, strawberry filling, light pineapple buttercream frosting, then given a hot fudge drizzle, topped with a cherry!
Neapolitan - We take our classic vanilla cake, fill it with our delicious strawberry filling, and top it off with our classic chocolate buttercream frosting. Vanilla, Chocolate, and strawberry? Yes please!
Butterfinger - This yellow cake is mixed with crushed Butterfinger pieces, then topped with a vanilla Butterfinger buttercream frosting, and topped with more Butterfinger candy pieces!
Molten Chocolate - Classic chocolate cupcake with a chocolate ganache filling, topped with a chocolate ganache frosting, then garnished with whipped cream and a cherry on top.
Turtle - Chocolate, pecan, and chocolate chip cake, topped with a caramel buttercream frosting, caramel drizzle, and pecan pieces.
Island Pineapple (seasonal) - A sweet pineapple yellow cake, topped with our very own pineapple butter cream frosting.
Caramel Macchiato - Coffee-caramel cake with a vanilla butter cream frosting and caramel drizzle.
Chocolate Covered Strawberry - Our chocolate cake is filled with a strawberry preserve filling, then topped with a fresh strawberry puree buttercream frosting and mini chocolate chips.
Raspberry Almond - An almond flavored cake filled with sweet raspberry cream, topped with almond butter cream frosting and a dallop of raspberry.
Caramel Apple (Seasonal)- A delicious apple cupcake topped with our vanilla butter cream frosting, topped with a caramel drizzle and crushed pecans.
Peanut Butter Surprise - We take our classic chocolate cupcake, top it with our peanut butter buttercream frosting and mini chocolate chips... and in the middle is a little surprise, but shhh... we can't tell!
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough - A yellow cake with cookie dough baked into the batter, topped with our chocolate butter cream frosting and a mini chocolate chip cookie.
French Toast - We start with a sweet maple cake, then top it with our maple buttercream frosting, garnished with a maple syrup drizzle and a dusting of powdered sugar.
Pumpkin Roll (seasonal) - This pumpkin cupcake is filled with a sweet cream cheese filling, then topped with our delicious cream cheese frosting. A fall classic!
Caramel Delight - A caramel cake, topped with our classic vanilla butter cream frosting, then drizzled with decadent caramel.
Chai Latte - A chai cupcake, topped with our vanilla butter cream frosting, garnished with a pinch of cinnamon on top!
Stuffed French Toast - A french toast cake, stuffed with cream cheese filling, topped with a maple butter cream frosting and a pinch of powdered sugar.
Oreo Express - A signature cupcake, this devil's food cake is topped with an Oreo buttercream frosting, and garnished with an Oreo cookie half.
Classic Vanilla - The classic cupcake! A vanilla cake, topped with vanilla bean buttercream frosting.
Classic Chocolate - This chocolate devil's food cake is topped with either our vanilla bean, or chocolate buttercream frosting.
Red Velvet - Perhaps the most well known American cupcake, our moist red velvet cake is topped with a delectible cream cheese frosting.
Wedding Bells - This classic vanilla cake is infused with a hint of almond flavoring, then topped with our classic almond buttercream frosting and crystal sanding sugar. Simplistic and delicious.
White Russian - Another of our signature cupcakes, we take a classic vanilla cake and add Kaluha and vodka to the mix, brush with Kaluha after baking, and top with a whipped frosting infused with a hint of Kaluha and cream. An adult's dream cupcake.
Buckeye - An Ohio classic honoring the Buckeyes! We start with a decadent devil's food cake, top it with our own peanut butter buttercream, and garnish it with a mini chocolate peanut butter buckeye! O-H !
Mandarin Orange - A sweet white cake mixed with a touch of mandarin flavor, topped with a sweet orange buttercream frosting, and garnished with a fresh mandarin slice.
Gone Bananas - This delicious treat starts with our own special banana cake, then gets topped off with a caramel glazed frosting, finished with mini butterscotch chips!
Boston Cream Pie - This classic yellow cake is injected with a sweet Bavarian cream, then topped off with a rich dark chocolate buttercream frosting! Another classic American concoction!
Pumpkin Patch (seasonal)- A moist pumpkin spice cake, topped with a vanilla and pumpkin spiced buttercream frosting, garnished with a sprinkle of cinnamon.
Short Stack (with bacon) - This one of a kind treat is what happens when breakfast meets cupcakes. We start with a sweet maple cake, topped with a maple glazed buttercream frosting, and finish it off with real crumbled honey bacon! Who says you can't have cupcakes first thing in the morning?!?
Andes Mint Chocolate - A rich devil's food with real Andes Mints baked into the cake, then topped with chocolate buttercream frosting, and garnished with Andes Mints on top!
Sweet Caroline - We've finally made our signature cupcake official! This delicious treat starts with a classic yellow cake, injected with a strawberry filling (which is super tasty for the record!); we then add a swirl of pink vanilla buttercream frosting, and top it off with a maraschino cherry!
If You Like Pina Colada - A summertime classic, this white cake is mixed with real pineapple, coconut oil, and a splash of rum; then topped with a "drunken" coconut buttercream frosting.
Key Lime Cake - A classic yellow cake is injected with a key lime filling, then topped with a green lime buttercream frosting. A perfect summer afternoon treat!
Campfire S'mores - A classic yellow cake, with real graham cracker crumbs baked in, then topped off with a vanilla buttercream, garnished with more crushed graham crackers and a chocolate square.
Cinnamon Toast - A yellow cake is mixed with fresh ground cinnamon, then baked to a golden brown. We top it off with a vanilla bean buttercream frosting, dusted with real cinnamon and sugar.
Luscious Lemon - This yellow cake is filled with a zesty lemon custard, then topped off with a delicious lemon buttercream frosting, and a lemon custard dollop.
Choc-o-holic - Chocolate lover? We've got just the thing for you! This devil's food chocolate cake is filled with chocolate Bavarian cream, then topped off with a rich chocolate buttercream frosting... we then drizzle it with a Dutch Chocolate syrup and add some mini chocolate chips to finish it off!
Chocolate Raspberry Truffle - We start with a classic devil's food chocolate cake filled with a raspberry filling, then top it off with a raspberry cream buttercream frosting, garnished with mini chocolate chips.
Cherry Chocolate Cream - A devil's food cake is filled with cherry filling, topped with a delicious cream cheese frosting, then topped with a cherry for a classic American look.
Peanut Butter & Jelly - We take a white cake and fill it with either grape or strawberry filling, then top it off with a peanutbutter buttercram frosting. Your childroom memories wrapped in a cupcake!
Pretty In Pink (seasonal) - A classic white cake with fresh strawberries folded into the mix, then topped off with a cream cheese frosting which also have a fresh strawberry puree added for just the right flavor.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Kiss - This devil's food chocolate cupcake is filled with our chocolate Bavarian cream, then topped with a ring of peanut butter buttercream, then garnished with chocolate sprinkles.
Malted Milk Ball - A classic yellow cake is mixed with crushed malted milk balls and malt powder, then topped with a light malt cocoa buttercream frosting, garnished with crushed malted milk balls on top.
Choc-o-nut Cream - A devil's food chocolate cake, filled with coconut cream, then topped with a chocolate buttercream frosting, garnished with toasted coconut shreds.
Reese's Pieces Peanutbutter Blast - This lavish peanut butter cupcake is topped with our classic peanut butter frosting, then topped with a generous portion of crushed Reese's Pieces.
Ginger Snap - Our classic yellow cake with ginger snap cookies folded into the mix, then topped with our classic vanilla buttercream frosting, with ginger snap cookie crumbles on top.
Spice Cake - A classic spice cake with a little extra ginger for taste, is topped off with our classic cream cheese frosting.
Carrot Cake - Classic American carrot cake topped with our very own cream cheese frosting and a candy carrot.
Blueberry Bliss - A classic white cake mixed with fresh blueberries in the batter, then filled with a blueberry preserve, and topped with blueberry cream cheese frosting.
Mint-Melt-Away - (seasonal) Mint chocolate cake topped with a green mint cream cheese frosting.
Egg Nog - (seasonal) Egg nog cake topped with eggnog butter cream frosting, garnished with a dash of nutmeg.
Peppermint Twist - (seasonal) White cake infused with peppermint emulsion, topped with vanilla butter cream frosting and garnished with crushed candy canes.
Drunken Irishman - A Killian's Irish Red sweet beer bread cake, topped with a Bailey's Irish Cream, cream cheese frosting.
Jack and Coke - A chocolate cake made with CocaCola, a Jack Daniels filling, and a Jack Daniels buttercream frosting. It's got a bite!
More cupcakes coming soon! Check back often for new recipes!
*Note - All of our cupcakes are made using shared equipment, which means all cupcakes may come in contact with nuts, tree nuts, soy, and milk. Please be advised if you or anyone enjoying our cupcakes has severe food allergies.